Dip the Fly Completely
In another medically bizarre teaching, Muhammad instructed that if a fly falls into your drink, you should dip it completely because one wing carries disease while the other carries the cure. This appears in Sahih Bukhari and reflects pre-scientific understanding of disease and medicine.
"The Prophet said 'If a house fly falls in the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (in the drink), for one of its wings has a disease and the other has the cure for the disease.'" — Sahih Bukhari 4:54:537
The Scientific Reality
Modern entomology and microbiology conclusively demonstrate this teaching is false:
- Flies carry pathogens on their bodies, including E. coli, Salmonella, and other harmful bacteria
- Neither wing contains a "cure"—this concept doesn't align with how disease or immune response works
- Dipping a fly completely increases contamination rather than neutralizing it
- Flies spread disease through contamination, not through a disease/cure wing system
- Modern food safety recommends discarding any food or drink contaminated by insects
Modern Defense Attempts
Some Muslims claim recent research found antimicrobial compounds in fly tissues. However:
- Such compounds exist in tiny amounts insufficient to neutralize contamination
- They're not located specifically in one wing vs. another
- Dipping a fly doesn't extract or activate these compounds effectively
- No credible study recommends intentionally contaminating beverages with flies
Biblical Contrast
The Bible's dietary and cleanliness laws promoted health without prescribing harmful practices. Leviticus contains detailed instructions about clean and unclean food, often with practical health benefits, but never recommends consuming contaminated food.
Questions to Consider
- If Muhammad received divine revelation, why prescribe a practice that increases contamination?
- Does this reflect 7th-century Arabian folk medicine rather than divine knowledge?
- Should Muslims follow this teaching despite modern food safety guidelines?
Conclusion
The fly wing cure is another example of Muhammad's teachings reflecting the limited medical understanding of his time rather than divine revelation. Modern science shows this practice increases contamination risk rather than providing any cure.
Related articles: Camel Urine as Medicine, Black Seed Cures Everything